Like pizza, the small city of Boone is often taken for granted.
It is not a major city but a college town and a popular retirement destination.
However, like pizza, Boone can also surprise you.
They not only have pizza chains but also have their own pizzerias with local flavors.
Whether visiting a loved one or just passing through, delicious pies await you.
Below are our favorite joints and restaurants offering the best pizza in Boone.
1. Mellow Mushroom Boone
805 W King St
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 865-1515
Craft beer, calzones, and unique stone-baked pizzas are available at Mellow Mushroom Boone.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Like its locations all over the country, Mellow Mushroom in Boone stands out.
Its quirky surroundings and pizzas are popular, making it a favorite spot among hungry locals.
Their characteristic pies have cutesy sauce swirls, while the walls are filled with art.
Try some of its most well-loved slices and pair them with draft beers and fun cocktails.
What to Order
Aside from the ever-famous Holy Shiitake Pie, a popular dish is Funky Q. Chicken.
It’s essentially a BBQ chicken pizza finished with a BBQ sauce swirl.
The flavors are sweet and smokey, and the pizza dough is soft and fluffy.
2. Capone’s Pizza
139 New Market Centre
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 265-1886
Capone’s Pizza is a laid-back, diner-style eatery with innovative pizzas and a long beer list.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Fancy eating an award-winning pizza in a nostalgic, movie-themed setting?
Head over to Capone’s Pizza for the best Chicago and New York-style pies in the area.
Situated inside New Market Centre, this diner-like eatery is brimming with various pies.
There are gourmet and stuffed pizzas, subs, turnovers, and pasta.
The topping combinations are diverse, giving you options for every craving.
Beers, both domestic and imported, are available to wash them down.
You’ll also enjoy the walls covered in movie posters from the 1980s and 1990s.
What to Order
Take a break from your meat-centric diet and indulge in a Veggie Pizza.
It features conventional pizza vegetables as well as broccoli and fresh garlic.
Alternatively, try Pistol Pete’s Pesto Pie.
Its pesto base with meatballs provides the most herbaceous and savory explosion possible.
Related: Must Eat Restaurants in Boone
3. Lost Province Brewing Company
130 N Depot St
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 265-3506
Lost Province Brewing Company delivers craft beer alongside wood-fired pizzas and seasonal cuisine.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Name a more iconic duo than pizza and beer—we’ll wait.
In Boone, Lost Province Brewing Company is the perfect place for that.
It’s a very popular hangout, particularly for groups looking to have a good time.
Craft beers come in various flavors, as do wood-fired pizzas.
They offer the best pizza in downtown Boone, all authentic Neapolitan style.
Try one of their specialty pizzas crafted with Italian ingredients, or make your own.
Have them made gluten-free or served with salads and appetizers for sharing.
There’s something for everyone, from vegans to kids, beer drinkers to cocktail lovers.
Enjoy the weekend’s live music while you “ciao” down these Italian treats.
What to Order
The Depot Street Pizza is well-known for its spicy sausages and cheese excess.
It goes well with any beer, is savory, and the dough is authentically Neapolitan.
Also See:
Best Pizza Restaurants in Charlotte
Raleigh: Pizza Places
Best Concord Pizza
4. Bella’s Italian Restaurant
190 Boone Heights Dr
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 386-6101
Bella’s Italian Restaurant in Boone Heights Shopping Center serves pizza, sandwiches, and Italian entrees.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Both family- and pet-friendly, Bella’s is one of the best pizza restaurants in Boone.
It’s warm and inviting, with delicious Italian cuisine and, of course, bottles of wine.
As for the show’s star, their pizzas, along with calzones and strombolis, are homemade.
It takes a little while to cook, but it’s well worth the wait.
It’s the ideal Italian hole-in-the-wall for bringing kids after a day of skiing.
What to Order
With all of the red pies we’ve recommended, we think a white pie is in order this time.
Cole’s White Pie is the best option for this.
The ingredients are simple (ricotta, spinach, garlic, and goat cheese), but the flavors are fantastic.
It’s incredibly cheesy yet powerful, with a buttery and creamy texture.
5. Carolina Pizza
454 W King St, Suite B
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 832-8018
Carolina Pizza is a family-friendly pizzeria serving pizza and casual fare with a high country flair.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
There’s no such thing as too much pizza, especially at Carolina Pizza.
The choices are endless, with over 15 topping combinations and a design-your-own option.
Every pizza is created and tossed by hand, with a South Carolina twist.
There are also subs, fresh salads, and other inventive menu items to check out.
Bring the whole family—there’s enough for everyone at the best pizza place in Boone.
What to Order
If you’ve never had steak on a pizza before, now is the time.
Order the Big Trouble in Little China, a delicious pizza with an oriental twist.
It has a honey mustard base, grilled steak, broccoli, and a spicy Thai sauce on top.
You can already tell how tasty it is just by reading the ingredients.
6. Boonies Chicago Style Pizza
610 Blowing Rock Rd
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 355-3033
Boonies Chicago Style Pizza serves authentic Chicago-style pizza seven days a week.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Good Chicago-style pizza is hard to come by, so if you find one, get it immediately.
Boonies Chicago Style Pizza is the ideal place to satisfy this need.
They serve authentic Chitown pies, from the thick crusts to the famous deep dish.
The cheese is just oozing from the sides as you separate each thick, juicy slice.
Even Chicagoans adore it, and there is nothing better outside the city.
What to Order
The Deep Dish Pies may appear small, but they’re packed with pepperoni and cheese.
The sauce is delightfully tangy and unifies the entire dish.
Related: Best Breakfast in Boone
7. Domino’s Pizza
208 Faculty St Ste 3
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 264-6507
Domino’s is a global pizzeria chain serving various pizzas, entrees, and sides.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Domino’s is a classic that will always stay in style for serious pizza connoisseurs.
It’s quick and straightforward, and the pies are consistently tasty, if slightly greasy.
But that is the ultimate draw, and everyone who has ever gone out for pizza is familiar with it.
Stop by Domino’s for the best pizza near you if you don’t have the time to explore.
What to Order
For a taste of sweet and savory, have the Honolulu Hawaiian.
It’s a traditional pineapple and ham topping combo that provides the ideal flavor layering.
Also See:
Best Pizza in Morrisville
Greensboro Pizzerias
Best Pizza in Wilmington, NC
8. Hungry Howie’s Pizza
668 Blowing Rock Rd
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 264-5004
Hungry Howie’s Pizza is a counter-service pizzeria known for its flavored crusts.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Are you looking forward to dining in peace with just you and your pizza?
Go directly to Hungry Howie’s Pizza for the top pizza in Boone.
With 50 years of experience, they’ve already mastered their signature flavored crust.
Paired with flavorful and fresh ingredients, they make the perfect, easy-to-love pies.
It’s the ideal spot for hungry locals in a rush or looking for a last-minute dinner.
What to Order
Have the Howie Special if you want pies with a little bit of everything.
It’s covered with classic pizza toppings and is everyone’s favorite for a reason.
They’re satisfying and filling, balanced yet flavorful.
9. Little Caesars
1435 Blowing Rock Rd
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 268-1199
Little Caesars is a fast-food restaurant serving pizza tossed in the homemade dough.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Little Caesars is another tried-and-true pizza that we’ve all enjoyed.
It has built a name for itself in the pizza industry with its trademark thin crust and low prices.
By making the dough in-house, the costs of preparing fresh pies are reduced.
They even managed to use high-quality ingredients while doing so.
Little Caesars is one of the best pizza places in Boone for affordable pizza meals.
Satisfy your cravings and fill yourself up without breaking the bank.
What to Order
Since you’re at Little Caesars for convenience, have a Classic with Cheese.
Even without all the extra toppings, it’s a cheesy masterpiece on its own.
It’s everyone’s favorite pie—children and picky eaters alike.
10. Farm to Flame
163 Boone Creek Dr
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 263-1111
Farm to Flame is Appalachian Mountain Brewery’s official food truck.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Wood-fired pies are always the best.
If you’re looking for the best Boone pizza, look no further than Farm to Flame.
This colorful food truck only uses the freshest, locally sourced ingredients.
When wood-fired, flavors are preserved while achieving the perfect charred crust.
The pizza menu is limited, but this only means that each pizza has been perfectly mastered.
What to Order
Only Italian Pizza combines tangy, savory, and cheesy flavors like no other.
It’s made with marinara sauce, Italian sausage, and three types of cheese.
It’s as good as it sounds and ideal for first-time visitors.
11. Speedway
1033 E King St
Boone, NC 28607
(828) 264-2285
Speedway is a gas station and convenience store offering grab-and-go meals.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
For convenience, Speedway offers the best pizza in Boone.
Being a gas station convenience store, Speedway is the place for the ultimate fast food.
Pizzas are a quick in-and-out experience for those rushing through the day.
However, no flavors are sacrificed here.
Whole pies are served hot, fresh, and effortlessly delicious.
If you’re just passing through, Speedway’s got your cravings covered.
What to Order
Nothing beats a traditional Pepperoni Pizza.
Speedway’s pepperoni is evenly distributed, and the cheese is off-the-charts ooey-gooey.
Also See:
Best Pizza Places in Hendersonville
Top Pizza in Nags Head
Murphy: Pizza Restaurants
Map of The Best Pizza Places in Boone
Best Pizza in Boone, NC: 11 Top Pizzerias for 2023
- Mellow Mushroom Boone
- Capone’s Pizza
- Lost Province Brewing Company
- Bella’s Italian Restaurant
- Carolina Pizza
- Boonies Chicago Style Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Hungry Howie’s Pizza
- Little Caesars
- Farm to Flame
- Speedway
