For Southwest Floridians, pizza is a comfort food to be worshiped.
That’s why you’ll find that the people of Bonita Springs flock to its many Italian-owned pizza places.
They have award-winning wings, house-made sauces, and crusts in various styles: New York, Jersey, Greek, Brooklyn, and Neapolitan.
This beach community loves having hot, fresh pizzas with a cold brew.
So, if you want to discover the best pizza in Bonita Springs, dive into our list below.
1. Grandpa’s Pizza
27030 Old 41 Rd
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
(239) 992-7119
Opened in 1980, this pizza shop serves fresh Neapolitan pies and a garlic sauce made using a secret process.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Grandpa’s is home to the best Bonita Springs pizza.
It’s beloved for its authentic Neapolitan style, with a thin, crispy crust, savory toppings, and rich sauce.
Its famous garlic sauce is made with oil, fresh garlic, parsley, and a small amount of balsamic vinegar to give it that kick.
The Italian owners hand-prepare every ingredient because every pizza is made fresh to order.
What to Order
We recommend the Tomato Pie for its savory sautéed tomato and garlic sauce topped with a generous amount of Pecorino Romano cheese.
Another amazing pie to try is Grandma’s Pizza, which uses tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese topped with Pecorino Romano cheese and the shop’s signature garlic sauce.
2. Leoni’s Pizzeria
4131 Bonita Beach Rd SW
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
(239) 947-4900
For over two decades, Leoni’s Pizzeria has been serving locally farmed ingredients, award-winning wings, and New England-style pizzas.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Leoni’s is the place to be if you want the best pizza in downtown Bonita Springs.
This casual eatery has attentive service, a friendly atmosphere, and a choice of free beer or wine to go with a pizza order.
Its New England-style pies take influence from Greek-style pizzas made inside a pan instead of an oven.
You get a thick crust with crispy edges and a lot of cheese.
What to Order
Try the sweet and salty Taco Pizza made with salsa, onions, tomatoes, jalapeños, and beef served with tangy sour cream.
You can also try one of its Philly cheesesteaks, like the Deluxe Cheese Steak, made with mushrooms, green peppers, and fried onions.
It also comes with a bag of chips.
Related: Must Eat Restaurants in Bonita Springs
3. Pino’s Pizzeria
24600 S Tamiami Trail #100
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
(239) 676-5332
This family-owned restaurant serves Italian entrées and Brooklyn-style pizzas.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
This casual mom-and-pop restaurant is where you can enjoy good Italian dishes and the top pizza in Bonita Springs.
It uses high-quality toppings, handmade dough, a lot of cheese blends, and Italian specialty ingredients for that authentic Italian taste.
If you like trying a variety of crusts, this place should be on your list.
You can get specialty pan pizzas or Sicilian thick and thin crusts that can either be gluten-free or the standard cheese.
What to Order
Check out the Meatball Parmigiana Sub made with meatballs drenched in red sauce, mozzarella, and Romano cheese.
As for pizza, try the Chicken Florentine one, made with tasty grilled chicken, creamy Alfredo sauce, pleasantly salty Romano cheese, and fresh mozzarella.
Also See:
Best Pizza Restaurants in Miami
Key West: Pizza Places
4. Carini’s Pizzaria & Trattoria
24611 Production Cir
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
(239) 949-7770
Carini’s Pizzaria and Trattoria is well-known for its perfectly cooked shrimp pasta, handmade ingredients, and New York-style pizzas.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
This family-owned pizzeria and pasta place offers fresh ingredients and handmade dishes.
Its garlic cheese bread is served piping hot with velvety and slightly tarty marinara sauce.
Its affordable pizzas have perfectly crunchy thin crusts and use a delicious homemade sauce and fresh ingredients.
This casual restaurant is perfect for Italian lunches and dinners with family and friends.
What to Order
The Barbecue Chicken pizza is a savory dish with bold flavors from the BBQ sauce, red onions, and diced chicken.
Check out its classic cheese pizza if you want to taste its homemade pizza sauce.
It’s made with signature sauce and the buttery richness of grande mozzarella.
5. Enzo’s Italian Bar & Restaurant
4351 Bonita Beach Rd SW
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
(239) 992-5555
Enzo’s Italian Bar & Restaurant opened in 1985, serving rich-flavored dishes and pizzas influenced by the cooking of small Italian towns.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Enzo’s is one of the best pizza restaurants in Bonita Springs when it comes to hefty Italian fare in a cozy space.
With low lighting and a relaxed ambiance, this place is excellent for enjoying well-cooked brick-oven pizzas.
Its homemade Sicilian pizzas use premium ingredients like milky burrata mozzarella, Canadian bacon, and fresh vegetables.
What to Order
We recommend the light and creamy Navona, a white pizza made with garlic, mozzarella, artichoke hearts, and thinly sliced zucchini.
You should also try one of its famous pasta, the Porcini Sacchetti Truffle Cream.
It’s stuffed pasta with porcini mushrooms, ricotta cheese, mushrooms, garlic, prosciutto, and truffle cream sauce.
6. ANY Pizzeria
10020 Coconut Rd #130
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
(239) 301-4727
This family-owned pizza shop opened in 2018 and serves New York-style pies that use locally sourced ingredients.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
If you’re looking for the best pizza place in Bonita Springs, made lovingly and specifically for Southwest Florida’s humidity, check this out.
The chef and owner tweaked his family’s old pizza recipe to make the hand-tossed dough crispier but no less flavorful.
The dishes here are a mix of traditional and modern creations, like the Lasagna Pizza, which is very filling and savory.
You can also order gluten-free crusts and other vegan-friendly choices.
What to Order
Of course, you have to try the signature pie, Lasagna Pizza.
It’s like lasagna, just without the pasta, made with ricotta, meatballs, sausage, and extra sauce.
Its rich sauce is the superstar and pairs well with the pleasant-smelling garlic knots that also use pizza dough.
The knots are slathered in garlic oil, basil, and parmesan and served with marinara.
7. Sharky’s Pizza Pub
4450 Bonita Beach Rd
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
(239) 986-0214
Sharky’s Pizza Pub offers hand-tossed Ohio-inspired pizzas, Italian entrées, and a full-service bar, all just a stone’s throw from Bonita Beach.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
The restaurant owner brought her father’s 1971 recipe to the Southwest Florida area to make delicious pies.
The pizzas have powdery crusts and are handmade using fresh ingredients and an Italian family recipe.
They’re classic but with unforgettable flavors ranging from creamy and zesty to tangy and nutty.
Sharky’s has intimate seating and a full bar with an Italian-inspired wine selection.
What to Order
We recommend the soft and meaty Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Flatbread with homemade dough, ranch dressing sauce, mozzarella, cheddar, onion, bacon, and chicken.
You should also try the savory Supreme Pizza made with pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, bacon, mozzarella, black olives, and mushrooms.
Also See:
Best Pizza Places in Boca Raton
Top Pizza in Brandon
8. Blackjack Pizza & Salads
28245 S Tamiami Trail
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
(239) 495-3422
This pizza franchise was founded in 1983 and serves made-from-scratch hand-tossed round and square pan pies.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
If you want a taste of the best pizza near you now, check out Blackjack for its variety of pizza selections.
It’s a delivery and takeout shop known for its fresh pizzas, whether it’s the regular round, a thin-crust pizza, or the square pan pie.
They have many specialty pizzas, and you can also make your own.
What to Order
Get the Pan Crust Cheesy Bread topped with lots of mozzarella and served with garlic, marinara, or ranch sauce.
If you want to taste all the meat toppings, get The Jackpot Pizza.
It’s made with black olives, ground beef, bacon, ham, Italian sausage, mushroom, onion, and green pepper.
9. Joey D’s Italian Restaurant
2356 Immokalee Rd
Naples, FL 34110
(239) 597-8545
This neighborhood restaurant with a full-service sports bar has been serving New York and Jersey-style pies for over two decades.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Joey D’s Italian Restaurant is perfect for those who want a fun and relaxed dining experience.
Here, you can enjoy specialty thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas with lots of toppings like broccoli, hot cherry peppers, salami, and meatballs, among others.
The pizzas are usually topped with mozzarella, parmesan, and sweet sauce.
What to Order
Try the Old Country Pizza, made with marinara sauce, tomatoes, basil, roasted garlic, olive oil, and fresh mozzarella.
Another favorite is the succulent Seafood Pizza with toppings like calamari, clams, mussels, sautéed shrimp, garlic, olive oil, and marinara sauce.
10. San Giuseppe Pizza
1431 Rail Head Blvd Unit 1
Naples, FL 34110
(239) 558-1216
San Giuseppe Pizza is a family-owned pizza joint that opened in 1972 and delivers New York-style pizzas, stuffed pies, and delicious calzones.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
This local landmark is one of the best pizza places in Bonita Springs for its variety of excellent crusts.
Here, you can get classic thin New York-style crusts or thicker stuffed pizzas by the slice or whole.
Patrons also love the square pizzas with lots of fresh, hand-cut toppings.
It only offers curbside pickup or delivery, but it sees a lot of traffic because of its affordable prices and tasty pies.
What to Order
One of our favorites is the Grandma Pizza, made using an old family recipe.
It’s a square pizza baked in a pan, so it comes in a thin and crispy crust with tomato sauce, garlic, mozzarella, and pesto sauce.
The Meatball and Ricotta Stuffed Pizza is another excellent pie to try.
This deep-dish pizza is filled with ricotta, meatballs, mozzarella, a small amount of tomato sauce, and marinara.
Also See:
Best Pizza Restaurants in Port St Lucie
Bradenton: Pizza Places
11. Pizzata Pizzeria + Aperitivo
1201 Piper Blvd
Naples, FL 34110
(239) 631-1021
Pizzata Pizzeria opened in North Naples in 2022 and served award-winning New York-style and Philadelphia-inspired pies.
Why We Recommend This Pizza Joint
Do you know that the best pizza in Bonita Springs and its surrounding areas is at Pizzata?
You can check it out yourself if you want the perfect sourdough crust and sauce made with tomatoes from Italy.
Its pizzas are excellent for anyone who wants a more robust flavor, chewy dough, and slightly sweet, tangy sauce.
This fast-casual restaurant has outdoor seating if you want to hang around with a drink after getting your order from the counter.
What to Order
Get one of its pre-meal bites like the Buffalo Chicken Lollipops made with chicken drumsticks in creamy hot buffalo sauce and a blue cheese dip.
As for pizza, one of our favorites is the Capricciosa pie.
It’s made with red sauce, mozzarella, Mediterranean olives, artichokes, mushrooms, and Italian ham.
Map of The Best Pizza Places in Bonita Springs
Best Pizza in Bonita Springs, FL: 11 Top Pizzerias for 2023
- Grandpa’s Pizza
- Leoni’s Pizzeria
- Pino’s Pizzeria
- Carini’s Pizzaria & Trattoria
- Enzo’s Italian Bar & Restaurant
- ANY Pizzeria
- Sharky’s Pizza Pub
- Blackjack Pizza & Salads
- Joey D’s Italian Restaurant
- San Giuseppe Pizza
- Pizzata Pizzeria + Aperitivo
